From Seed Money to Breakout Success

Success in Silicon Valley is usually measured in spectacular numbers: multibillion-dollar valuations, enormous funding rounds, and stock market debuts. Trace those numbers backward, however, and the story begins somewhere much more modest—with someone writing a first check to a company that has few customers and perhaps not even a finished product.
Even today’s most celebrated technology companies were never guaranteed to succeed. Their founders had ambitious visions, but customer demand remained uncertain. No one could know whether the technology would become a viable business. At that uncertain moment, some people recognized the possibilities and agreed to share the risk.
They were seed investors—the people who provide capital at a company’s earliest stages.
An individual seed investor’s first check may start at a few hundred thousand dollars. With several investors participating, a startup may raise a few million. That money does not buy an established success. It buys time: time to build a product, find the first customers, and demonstrate that a business can work.
Understanding these investors brings the origins of Silicon Valley innovation into sharper focus. Buying shares in an established company and backing a market that barely exists require very different kinds of judgment.
Seeing the Person Before the Company Takes Shape
Ali Partovi of Neo, an early investor in Anysphere, the company behind the AI coding tool Cursor, offers one example.
According to Forbes, Partovi encountered co-founder Michael Truell’s technical ability through a hands-on programming challenge when Truell was still a student at MIT. When Truell later started a company, Partovi became an early investor. Before backing a vision of a vast market, he recognized the ability of someone who might help create it.
At the seed stage, financial statements offer limited guidance. There may be no revenue at all. Feedback from a handful of customers may constitute nearly all the available evidence of demand. Investors therefore ask a different set of questions.
How deeply does the founder understand the problem? Can the team turn difficult technology into a usable product? When customers respond differently than expected, can the founders learn and adjust? Can they persuade talented people to join them?
Passion alone is insufficient. Almost every founder professes belief in the business. What matters is whether technical skill, the ability to execute, and an understanding of customers support that belief.
Finding Large Markets in Everyday Frustrations
Good early investors do more than make sweeping predictions about the future. They also examine the inconveniences people have learned to tolerate.
Semil Shah of Haystack, an early investor in the collaborative design platform Figma, illustrates this approach. Haystack lists Figma, DoorDash, and Instacart among its early investments. These companies serve different purposes, but they share a connection: each recognized an opportunity to change how people work or buy things.
Figma’s underlying question was straightforward: Why couldn’t people work together on a design directly in a browser?
At first, such a change might look like a modest improvement to existing software. But when it changes how people collaborate, exchange feedback, and organize their work, it can become the foundation of a substantial business.
Christian Lawless of Conversion Capital, an investor in the corporate spending platform Ramp, offers another example. Forbes credits him with leading the firm’s investment in Ramp. The company demonstrates that even familiar activities such as corporate card use and expense management can offer room for a new software business.
Market size, then, is only part of the equation. Investors

The First Checks and the Ability to Read People

Behind Silicon Valley’s Biggest Ideas

What did early investors see before these companies became unicorns?

Success in Silicon Valley is usually measured in spectacular numbers: multibillion-dollar valuations, enormous funding rounds, and stock market debuts. Trace those numbers backward, however, and the story begins somewhere much more modest—with someone writing a first check to a company that has few customers and perhaps not even a finished product.

Even today’s most celebrated technology companies were never guaranteed to succeed. Their founders had ambitious visions, but customer demand remained uncertain. No one could know whether the technology would become a viable business. At that uncertain moment, some people recognized the possibilities and agreed to share the risk.

They were seed investors—the people who provide capital at a company’s earliest stages.

An individual seed investor’s first check may start at a few hundred thousand dollars. With several investors participating, a startup may raise a few million. That money does not buy an established success. It buys time: time to build a product, find the first customers, and demonstrate that a business can work.

Understanding these investors brings the origins of Silicon Valley innovation into sharper focus. Buying shares in an established company and backing a market that barely exists require very different kinds of judgment.

Seeing the Person Before the Company Takes Shape

Ali Partovi of Neo, an early investor in Anysphere, the company behind the AI coding tool Cursor, offers one example.

According to Forbes, Partovi encountered co-founder Michael Truell’s technical ability through a hands-on programming challenge when Truell was still a student at MIT. When Truell later started a company, Partovi became an early investor. Before backing a vision of a vast market, he recognized the ability of someone who might help create it.

At the seed stage, financial statements offer limited guidance. There may be no revenue at all. Feedback from a handful of customers may constitute nearly all the available evidence of demand. Investors therefore ask a different set of questions.

How deeply does the founder understand the problem? Can the team turn difficult technology into a usable product? When customers respond differently than expected, can the founders learn and adjust? Can they persuade talented people to join them?

Passion alone is insufficient. Almost every founder professes belief in the business. What matters is whether technical skill, the ability to execute, and an understanding of customers support that belief.

Finding Large Markets in Everyday Frustrations

Good early investors do more than make sweeping predictions about the future. They also examine the inconveniences people have learned to tolerate.

Semil Shah of Haystack, an early investor in the collaborative design platform Figma, illustrates this approach. Haystack lists Figma, DoorDash, and Instacart among its early investments. These companies serve different purposes, but they share a connection: each recognized an opportunity to change how people work or buy things.

Figma’s underlying question was straightforward: Why couldn’t people work together on a design directly in a browser?

At first, such a change might look like a modest improvement to existing software. But when it changes how people collaborate, exchange feedback, and organize their work, it can become the foundation of a substantial business.

Christian Lawless of Conversion Capital, an investor in the corporate spending platform Ramp, offers another example. Forbes credits him with leading the firm’s investment in Ramp. The company demonstrates that even familiar activities such as corporate card use and expense management can offer room for a new software business.

Market size, then, is only part of the equation. Investors

Even today’s most celebrated technology companies were never guaranteed to succeed. Their founders had ambitious visions, but customer demand remained uncertain. No one could know whether the technology would become a viable business. At that uncertain moment, some people recognized the possibilities and agreed to share the risk.

They were seed investors—the people who provide capital at a company’s earliest stages.

An individual seed investor’s first check may start at a few hundred thousand dollars. With several investors participating, a startup may raise a few million. That money does not buy an established success. It buys time: time to build a product, find the first customers, and demonstrate that a business can work.

Understanding these investors brings the origins of Silicon Valley innovation into sharper focus. Buying shares in an established company and backing a market that barely exists require very different kinds of judgment.

Hands holding a miniature tree and stacked coins, symbolizing sustainable financial growth

Seeing the Person Before the Company Takes Shape

Ali Partovi of Neo, an early investor in Anysphere, the company behind the AI coding tool Cursor, offers one example.

According to Forbes, Partovi encountered co-founder Michael Truell’s technical ability through a hands-on programming challenge when Truell was still a student at MIT. When Truell later started a company, Partovi became an early investor. Before backing a vision of a vast market, he recognized the ability of someone who might help create it.

At the seed stage, financial statements offer limited guidance. There may be no revenue at all. Feedback from a handful of customers may constitute nearly all the available evidence of demand. Investors therefore ask a different set of questions.

How deeply does the founder understand the problem? Can the team turn difficult technology into a usable product? When customers respond differently than expected, can the founders learn and adjust? Can they persuade talented people to join them?

Passion alone is insufficient. Almost every founder professes belief in the business. What matters is whether technical skill, the ability to execute, and an understanding of customers support that belief.

Collage of five investors with the headline “The Seed 100: The best early-stage investors of 2024” on a blue background.

Finding Large Markets in Everyday Frustrations

Good early investors do more than make sweeping predictions about the future. They also examine the inconveniences people have learned to tolerate.

Semil Shah of Haystack, an early investor in the collaborative design platform Figma, illustrates this approach. Haystack lists Figma, DoorDash, and Instacart among its early investments. These companies serve different purposes, but they share a connection: each recognized an opportunity to change how people work or buy things.

Figma’s underlying question was straightforward: Why couldn’t people work together on a design directly in a browser?

At first, such a change might look like a modest improvement to existing software. But when it changes how people collaborate, exchange feedback, and organize their work, it can become the foundation of a substantial business.

Christian Lawless of Conversion Capital, an investor in the corporate spending platform Ramp, offers another example. Forbes credits him with leading the firm’s investment in Ramp. The company demonstrates that even familiar activities such as corporate card use and expense management can offer room for a new software business.

Market size, then, is only part of the equation. Investors

Leave a Reply